Guardian Nature School Team Contact Blog Project Noah Facebook Project Noah Twitter

A worldwide community photographing and learning about wildlife

Join Project Noah!
nature school apple icon

Project Noah Nature School visit nature school

Philadelphia Vireo

Vireo philadelphicus

2 Species ID Suggestions

RyanWarner
RyanWarner 11 years ago
Warbling Vireo
Vireo gilvus


Sign in to suggest organism ID

9 Comments

RogerHagerman
RogerHagerman 11 years ago

Go for it

Liam
Liam 11 years ago

Hi Roger, mind if I seek further advice on this bird via an external site?

RogerHagerman
RogerHagerman 11 years ago

The vireo bird is the same bird just different direction so you can see different angle. I think it's a Philly because of the color and the bill thank you for helping me.

RyanWarner
RyanWarner 11 years ago

Although...I think this spotting and the one you linked Liam are one in the same. Look at the branch that the bird is perched on, they are identical. So I retract my previous statement and hold firm of this spotting and the other spotting being a Warbling Vireo

RyanWarner
RyanWarner 11 years ago

I could see where this might be a Philly, however I'm not seeing enough yellow on the neck and belly (what you can see of it) for me to change my mind. But, I believe this is one of those cases were actual experience will out weigh book knowledge, so basically I think Liam is right.

Liam
Liam 11 years ago

I initially agreed with Warbling Vireo, but after seeing the second photo (http://www.projectnoah.org/spottings/125... - you may want to add that one into this spotting), I'm inclined towards Philly vireo based on the loral angle of the supercilium, the bright color of the underparts, and the short tail.

RyanWarner
RyanWarner 11 years ago

Very nice capture of a Warbling Vireo. Note the small size, lack of wing bars and faint eye line, all common traits of the Warbling Vireo.

RogerHagerman
RogerHagerman 11 years ago

No wing bar

alicelongmartin
alicelongmartin 11 years ago

Looks like a Vireo to me. but it is hard to see if there is bars on his wing.

RogerHagerman
Spotted by
RogerHagerman

Marion, Michigan, USA

Spotted on Aug 12, 2012
Submitted on Aug 13, 2012

Related Spottings

White-Eyed Vireo Hutton's Vireo Huttons Vireo Red-eyed Vireo

Nearby Spottings

Spotting House Wren Downy Woodpecker Northern Cardinal
Noah Guardians
Noah Sponsors
join Project Noah Team

Join the Project Noah Team