Guardian Nature School Contact Blog Project Noah Facebook Project Noah Twitter

A global citizen science platform
to discover, share and identify wildlife

Join Project Noah!
nature school apple icon

Nature School For Teachers - Fall 2020 Launch! visit nature school

Western Poplar Clearwing

Paranthrene robiniae

Description:

Wonderful male, wasp-mimicking moth! The wings have a clear window giving it the Clearwing common name. This mimics our local California Paper Wasp quite well: http://www.projectnoah.org/spottings/140.... This species is described as having the first three segments being black but this one is a yellow variety.

Habitat:

Buckwheat in riparian area

Notes:

First for Project Noah! Finally confirmed by Bug Guide and of course bayucca :)

Species ID Suggestions



Sign in to suggest organism ID

15 Comments

Hi bayucca, thanks for your reply. Not sure what you mean with your last sentence but I appreciate your efforts with identification!

bayucca
bayucca 6 years ago

Cindy, I certainly checked Cissuvora as well ;-)...
Very similar indeed and tricky to compare with only this picture on bugguide. Trusting my eyes, I see some mince differences: In the middle of the dark band I only see one yellow ring in yours and in Cissuvora I see there an additional black ring and the yellow ring looks like being more prominent or broader in yours. The color of the antennae is also slightly different. I am not sure if I see no darker feathery-like parts on the hindwing in yours and this feature present in Cissuvora. Usually I trust my eyes, so I would still "vote" for Paranthrene robiniae. I would not be so concerned about being a lucky loser, important we have an ID at the end, whatever it is...

Sckel
Sckel 6 years ago

thanks cindy. :)

Thank you Ashley! I was going to have that one as the first but thought the amazing mimicry wouldn't be as obvious. I may end up switching it anyway :)

AshleyT
AshleyT 6 years ago

Love the second photo!

Thank you kyleighphelps, Sckel and bayucca. Sckel, I feel the same way about your collection! bayucca, I was looking at Cissuvora ampelopsis as a possibility but was unable to find more than one reference that's credible. Hoping Bug Guide has an ID soon :)

kyleighphelps
kyleighphelps 6 years ago

Beautiful!

Sckel
Sckel 6 years ago

wonderful. I really admire your collection, cindy.

bayucca
bayucca 6 years ago

Based on the markings overall, I would have suggested Paranthrene robiniae as well, beside the black parts you already mentioned. Let's see what bugguide means. I also noticed quite a great variability which makes the ID not really easier...
http://bugguide.net/node/view/139818/bgi...
http://bugguide.net/node/view/143915/bgp...
http://bugguide.net/node/view/143916/bgp...

Thank you so much, Joan!

joan6153
joan6153 6 years ago

Fantastic spotting and photos!

Thank you Gilma!

Fantastic spotting!! Great series of a gorgeous creature. Thank you for sharing, CindyBinghamKeiser

It is amazing! I almost didn't photograph it because I thought it was the wasp when I took a glance. So glad I did! I've been looking for this species for over 2 years :)

Fyn Kynd
Fyn Kynd 6 years ago

Right down to the markings behind the head!

Poway, California, USA

Spotted on May 19, 2014
Submitted on May 20, 2014

Related Spottings

Dusky clearwing

Nearby Spottings

Carpet Beetle Stiletto Fly Paper Wasp Crambid Snout Moth
Noah Guardians
Noah Sponsors