Guardian Nature School Team Contact Blog Project Noah Facebook Project Noah Twitter

A worldwide community photographing and learning about wildlife

Join Project Noah!
nature school apple icon

Project Noah Nature School visit nature school

Great Kiskadee

Pitangus sulphuratus

7 Comments

bayucca
bayucca 9 years ago

I would also tend to Pitangus sulphuratus, but the pictures are not in best shape to be 100% of the safe side, but some criteria would indicate Great Kiskadee more than others.

Rosa Maria
Rosa Maria 9 years ago

The rufus color on the wings (Pic #4) made me think it was a Great Kiskadee and the bill did not look as short as a Social Flycatcher, but pictures can be deceiving with the lighting and angle. Cool. I'm glad to help in some way. :)

James McNair
James McNair 9 years ago

Thank you Rosa and Ashley. Based on the suggestions I am going with the Social Flycatcher. The similarities are amazing but the breadth of the white band on the head, especially in picture 3 makes me lean towards the Flycatcher as it seems to be slightly thicker than that of the Great Kiskadee. Great example of cooperative discussion and also shows how smart you all are with such difficult ids of some poor quality pictures....thanks again! If someone else disagrees with my choice and can offer me good reason to change I am certainly open to suggestion.

AshleyT
AshleyT 9 years ago

There's also boat-billed flycatcher, but they have massive bills. You can't completely rule out lesser kiskadee since birds don't always follow range maps, but it's probably safe to call it a great kiskadee

Rosa Maria
Rosa Maria 9 years ago

So do you think it is a Great Kiskadee, Ashley? Or are there other similar species I overlooked?

AshleyT
AshleyT 9 years ago

Social Flycatchers are noticeably different by their tiny bill. Assuming all these photos are the same individual, social flycatcher is easily ruled out by the bill not being tiny.

Rosa Maria
Rosa Maria 9 years ago

Hey James, so I think it is a Great Kiskadee, but I may have overlooked similar flycatchers. The Lesser Kiskadee and the Social Flycatcher also look very similar to the Great Kiskadee, but the Lesser doesn't occur in Costa Rica. As for the other two it appears more like a Great Kiskadee. Here are two links for identification:
http://www.1-costaricalink.com/costa_ric...
http://www.1-costaricalink.com/costa_ric...

Also if you want to read up on the Social Flycatcher: http://neotropical.birds.cornell.edu/por...

I guess if it is still undecided you can say Tyrannidae for the family. They are all flycatchers. Hope this helped. I'm really interested in what you think.

James McNair
Spotted by
James McNair

Alajuela, Costa Rica

Spotted on May 18, 2009
Submitted on May 18, 2014

Related Spottings

pecho amarillo Benteveo Benteveo común Great Kiskadee

Nearby Spottings

Turkey Vulture Variable Seedeater (female) Hooded Mantis Grey-headed Chachalaca
Noah Guardians
Noah Sponsors
join Project Noah Team

Join the Project Noah Team