Guardian Nature School Team Contact Blog Project Noah Facebook Project Noah Twitter

A worldwide community photographing and learning about wildlife

Join Project Noah!
nature school apple icon

Project Noah Nature School visit nature school

Gall

Harmandia tremulae

Species ID Suggestions



Sign in to suggest organism ID

29 Comments (1–25)

Mark Ridgway
Mark Ridgway 11 years ago

Such spottings should be capable of appearing under 2 categories but the system can't handle that. They still excite my tastebuds Lars.

LarsKorb
LarsKorb 11 years ago

Thanks, Jolly ^^

Jolly Ibañez
Jolly Ibañez 11 years ago

Lars, no matter what the classification is, its still a beautiful picture. Nice find.

LarsKorb
LarsKorb 11 years ago

Well...some ranger can take the effort to put it where ever PN considers it to fit well - personally, I'd leave it where it is. Whoever feels different is free to take action on this spotting.

TKBotting
TKBotting 11 years ago

I'm going to go ahead and agree with Mark on this one. I think it is best filed under arthropod. I would put a photo of a wasp's egg under arthropod, so I think I'd have to put its gall under arthropod too. So cool! I have some gall photos I hope to get around to posting soon.

LarsKorb
LarsKorb 11 years ago

Mark, I think it's well kept in the famous "other" category, since it's a plantogen just caused by an insect. But it is definetely no insect. And hey, who really cares about categories...?

Amazing! Thanks for the info Mark!

Mark Ridgway
Mark Ridgway 11 years ago

Chief and Leana... Galls are created usually by insects which 'irritate' a plant chemically to cause abnormal cell growth for the purpose of creating a dwelling. They can appear on many parts of a plant including leaves, buds, stems. Amazing huh!

uhmm...what are galls?

Mark Ridgway
Mark Ridgway 11 years ago

Make this an arthropod spotting?

LarsKorb
LarsKorb 11 years ago

Thanks....as Sergio mentioned, Billiards came up my mind at first sight :)

Eva Varga
Eva Varga 11 years ago

Cool galls ... they look like little berries. :)

CourtneyVerk
CourtneyVerk 11 years ago

These look so perfectly spherical. Beautiful photos.

tibiprada
tibiprada 11 years ago

a what?

LarsKorb
LarsKorb 11 years ago

That's it, Martin - thanks a lot!

MartinL
MartinL 11 years ago

How does this look for an ID? ( I don't think Jaffas grow on poplars=) )
http://bugguide.net/node/view/600055
http://www.insektenbox.de/zweifl/espgal....

LarsKorb
LarsKorb 11 years ago

LOL, Argy - you made my day :D

Mark Ridgway
Mark Ridgway 11 years ago

Great Lars... It's a Jaffa tree http://www.flickr.com/photos/78001486@N0...

LarsKorb
LarsKorb 11 years ago

Initially I thought it could only be the Red-Pea-Gall...but like you mentioned, it grows exclusively on Querci

LarsKorb
LarsKorb 11 years ago

Thanks Martin - I am not certain about the leaves...I think it's a Poplar species. And yes, you're right, most of these galls are on Quercus species. Cynips sp. is also the name of the wasp that's responsible.

Jeannette
Jeannette 11 years ago

Great spotting Lars :)

MartinL
MartinL 11 years ago

Nice Lars. They seem to be wasps galls. Here is a 'wasp eats wasp'. http://chrisraper.org.uk/Galls/index.htm...
Do you know the plant species? Many of these galls seem to be on Quercus

LarsKorb
LarsKorb 11 years ago

Thanks all.
Sergio, funnily I had a similar thought :D

Maria dB
Maria dB 11 years ago

cool spotting, Lars!

Sergio Monteiro
Sergio Monteiro 11 years ago

Do german bugs play billiards?

LarsKorb
Spotted by
LarsKorb

Hohenhorn, Schleswig-Holstein (Landmasse), Germany

Spotted on Jul 5, 2012
Submitted on Jul 5, 2012

Related Spottings

mangrove gall? Spotting Sea urchin Gall?

Nearby Spottings

Yucca Spotting Bindweed Hypoxylon
Noah Guardians
Noah Sponsors
join Project Noah Team

Join the Project Noah Team