Guardian Nature School Team Contact Blog Project Noah Facebook Project Noah Twitter

A worldwide community photographing and learning about wildlife

Join Project Noah!
nature school apple icon

Project Noah Nature School visit nature school

Garza - Heron

Butorides sp.

Habitat:

Villa Alejandra, Municipio de Altamira, Huila, Colombia

Notes:

This foto was taken in an area that will be affected by the Quimbo Dam currently under construction. Esta foto fue tomado en una zona que sera afectada por la Represa del Quimbo actualmente bajo construcción

2 Species ID Suggestions

Liam
Liam 11 years ago
Striated Heron
Butorides striata BirdForum


Sign in to suggest organism ID

7 Comments

LarryGraziano
LarryGraziano 11 years ago

In these South American countries there is a great likelihood that range information is quite wrong due to the lack of funding and prominent professionals. Furthermore, many areas are only accessible to the most intrepid. I have documented species in my area of Costa Rica that were only known to exist in different elevations and climates over 50 miles away. With that said, and based on your in-depth commentary, it might be prudent to leave the name of this individual as Heron or Garza (in spanish) and leave the scientific name as Butorides sp. Naturally, I am completely amenable to any final suggestion you may have as you are an expert in this field. Thanks Liam.

Liam
Liam 11 years ago

Googling around, it appears the Green Heron range maps vary from site to site. Xeno-canto doesn't even show the range extending to Colombia. Here's what Birdforum says regarding the range of Green Heron in South America:
"Restricted to coastal N. Colombia and Venezuela. Also a few records from Ecuador, C. Colombia, and Suriname."

On eBird, it shows that Striated Heron is much more likely than Green at any rate. I think All About Birds' range map is a bit inaccurate.

That said, the two species in their juvenile plumage are very tough to differentiate, but particularly with a shot like this. An ID based on field marks would be unlikely.

LarryGraziano
LarryGraziano 11 years ago

I think this is so dark that it would be difficult to truly know which species it is.

Creo que con Garza estas bien.

auntnance123
auntnance123 11 years ago

Not to muddy the waters further but I would have guessed juvenile black-crowned night heron (also within the range) because of the posture and the thickness of the bill.(http://www.allaboutbirds.org/guide/black-crowned_night-heron/id) It is a difficult one with the distant and backlighting of the photo.

EntreAguas
EntreAguas 11 years ago

So which is it?

Fyn  Kynd
Fyn Kynd 11 years ago

No it's not... look at the map on my link.

Liam
Liam 11 years ago

Green Heron is out of range for the mapped location.

EntreAguas
Spotted by
EntreAguas

Huila, Colombia

Spotted on Mar 9, 2013
Submitted on Mar 12, 2013

Related Spottings

Little Green Heron Garza de lava (Lava Heron) Green Heron Green Heron

Nearby Spottings

Tuna - Prickly-Pear Cactus conejo de cola de algodón - cottontail rabbit Primrose Flag Tijereta Sabanera - Fork-tailed Flycatcher
Noah Guardians
Noah Sponsors
join Project Noah Team

Join the Project Noah Team