Guardian Nature School Team Contact Blog Project Noah Facebook Project Noah Twitter

A worldwide community photographing and learning about wildlife

Join Project Noah!
nature school apple icon

Project Noah Nature School visit nature school

Juvenile pale chanting goshawk

Melierax canorus

Species ID Suggestions



Sign in to suggest organism ID

18 Comments

staccyh
staccyh 9 years ago

Thanks! Have a good holiday as well!

AshleyT
AshleyT 9 years ago

Haha yay! Have a great rest of the time you are there!

staccyh
staccyh 9 years ago

Hm... ok, well I think I'd rather avoid finding one (or it finding me rather!), but if it happens I promise I will have my camera ready! :)

AshleyT
AshleyT 9 years ago

Everyone that doesn't want to find one usually gets found by one ;) I of course spent my whole two weeks looking for them and can't turn one up!

staccyh
staccyh 9 years ago

I wouldn't have the first clue of where to, or how to, find a cobra I'm not going to lie. I think I should probably leave that to someone else! :p

AshleyT
AshleyT 9 years ago

Well can't wait to see what else you find, good luck! I was there this time last year and really miss the warmth haha. If you find any cobras I will be super jealous!

staccyh
staccyh 9 years ago

I am! Just until the 14th then back to the UK :/

AshleyT
AshleyT 9 years ago

That is annoying! Are you still in South Africa?

staccyh
staccyh 9 years ago

I'm definitely no expert - I find it difficult to keep them all straight too! My guide doesn't have any pics of the juvenile, which is kind of annoying.

AshleyT
AshleyT 9 years ago

Weird, my field guide shows them having pretty wide bands on the tail as a juvenile. Everything else on it looks right though. I'm sure they know what they're talking about more than I do though, SA has so many raptors it's hard for me to keep them straight!

staccyh
staccyh 9 years ago

ok, so I put this on a fb group and it turns out that its a juvenile pale chanting goshawk! Thanks for all your help Ashley :)

AshleyT
AshleyT 9 years ago

Yea based off of range, the back, and the tail, steppe buzzard was the only one that made sense to me haha. Glad you think so too!

staccyh
staccyh 9 years ago

Yes indeed we do! I think you might be right about the juvenile Steppe buzzard because this doesn't look like anything I have in my bird guide either. It says that the juvenile has a paler eye colour and that it lacks the terminal tail band, so it fits the description. But you're right its difficult without seeing the front of the bird. It was so far away from us, so this is really the best I could do! :/

AshleyT
AshleyT 9 years ago

Y'all sure do have a lot of faith in me haha. This is the third time I've looked at this bird. Best I can do is immature Steppe Buzzard. I've gone through all the raptors in my field guide, and it's tough without being able to see the front of the bird. Field guide is super handy though in allowing me to rule out a lot of birds just by range! Google photos of the immatures though and see what you think!

staccyh
staccyh 9 years ago

Thanks James! Yea hopefully Ashley can help.. I'm at a loss!

James McNair
James McNair 9 years ago

Possibly a Eurasian Sparrowhawk (Accipiter nisus)? Hope Ashley can nail this one! Nice images

staccyh
staccyh 9 years ago

Thanks Josh! Just wish I knew what it was. I'm not very good with id'ying birds of prey as you may have noticed ;)

JoshuaGSmith
JoshuaGSmith 9 years ago

I love the photo where it is flying and you can see the tail fanned out!

staccyh
Spotted by
staccyh

Siyancuma Local Municipality, Northern Cape, South Africa

Spotted on Dec 27, 2014
Submitted on Jan 1, 2015

Related Spottings

Azor lagartijero (Eastern chanting goshawk) Eastern Chanting Goshawk Dark Chanting Goshawk Pale chanting goshawk

Nearby Spottings

Stick mantid Red eyed bulbul Frog Robber fly with prey
Noah Guardians
Noah Sponsors
join Project Noah Team

Join the Project Noah Team