Guardian Nature School Team Contact Blog Project Noah Facebook Project Noah Twitter

A worldwide community photographing and learning about wildlife

Join Project Noah!
nature school apple icon

Project Noah Nature School visit nature school

Lesser Goldfinch

Carduelis psaltria

Description:

Winter male this finch hasn't gotten his full yellow color yet. Will end up getting a black cap and wing markings.

Habitat:

Bouncing from bushes to trees in search of seeds.

Notes:

Spotted flying in a flock of American Goldfinch and Pine Siskin.

1 Species ID Suggestions

Cody.conway
Cody.conway 11 years ago
American Goldfinch
Spinus tristis


Sign in to suggest organism ID

8 Comments

Liam
Liam 11 years ago

Both American and Lesser bill color varies. Both can have dark or pale bills. Americans have pale bills in alternate plumage, and dark in basic.

Jellis
Jellis 11 years ago

Wish I had better shots but these birds move too fast for my camera. If you notice all 3 were there at the same time and in the same tree. It's like when I see Bushtits flying with Chickadees.
Liam a question about the 1st and 2nd shots with the color of the bill.

Liam
Liam 11 years ago

1st shot shows a Lesser Goldfinch - green mantle and black on the cap are typical of the species. Black on the terminal end of the tail also helps rule out American, which only show black on the outer edges.
2nd shot shows an American Goldfinch female - note difference in color and patterning.
3rd shot is a Pine Siskin - bill is too skinny for House Finch and there is white on the tertials. The yellow on the wingbars is not visible on all birds, particularly females, and would be difficult to see from a shadowed shot like this.

ForestDragon
ForestDragon 11 years ago

Oh, Hema, you might be right. I am not used to seeing the Lesser Goldfinches. The coloration seems to be more consistent with the yellow under the tail and the narrow wingbars of the first bird. The second bird could be a pale adult female. (Where's Liam when I need him?)
http://www.allaboutbirds.org/guide/Lesse...

Take a look, Jellis, and see what you think.

Hema  Shah
Hema Shah 11 years ago

any possibility of it being Lesser Gold Finch at all?

Cody.conway
Cody.conway 11 years ago

Third picture is a house finch based on streaking on the chest - Lack of golden wingbar can rule out Pine Siskin. And based on location House Finch is also best fit for the third picture. The first two are as said winter American Goldfinch.

jflatham78
jflatham78 11 years ago

Warbler?

ForestDragon
ForestDragon 11 years ago

Hi Jellis! The first two pictures look like an American Goldfinch, Spinus tristis in nonbreeding plumage. House Finches have streaking on their bellies. The bird in the first two pictures does not. The third picture could be a House Finch but it is hard to tell.
http://www.birds.cornell.edu/pfw/AboutBi...
http://www.allaboutbirds.org/guide/Ameri...

Jellis
Spotted by
Jellis

Hayward, California, USA

Spotted on Jan 16, 2013
Submitted on Jan 16, 2013

Related Spottings

putter of distelvink (Carduelis carduelis) European Goldfinch Goldfinch European Goldfinch

Nearby Spottings

Song Sparrow Yellow-bellied Sapsucker Sooty Fox Sparrow Yellow-bellied Sapsucker
Noah Guardians
Noah Sponsors
join Project Noah Team

Join the Project Noah Team