Guardian Nature School Team Contact Blog Project Noah Facebook Project Noah Twitter

A worldwide community photographing and learning about wildlife

Join Project Noah!
nature school apple icon

Project Noah Nature School visit nature school

Song Thrush

Turdus philomelos

Description:

Song Thrush Turdus philomelos

Species ID Suggestions



Sign in to suggest organism ID

14 Comments

Yes, certainly change it back. Apparently Young female moulting Blackbirds are often mistaken for Thrushes!

DavidGutiérrez
DavidGutiérrez 10 years ago

Ok, thanks for the information! I tried to take more pictures of the little ones yesterday, but their mother was around and she started to feel uncomfortable so I gave up. Do I change the tittle and the species then?

She definitely looks more like a Blackbird now, no sign of the white feathers which caused the confusion.
Check this thread out: http://www.birdforum.net/showthread.php?...
Yours could have been the same. Youngsters look like they are coming on well also.
We rarely see either species here, conditions are not quite right for their requirements but they do occur in some of the parks which have better soil!

DavidGutiérrez
DavidGutiérrez 10 years ago

I've added some new pictures! I hope you can guess the species now :)

DavidGutiérrez
DavidGutiérrez 10 years ago

Ok, I will try to take more photos. Let's see if one of these days I manage to capture her babies!

The mystery deepens, there is no doubt the male is a Blackbird, we will just have to wait for her to get off the nest when you have your camera handy. Aberrant or hybrid is most likely, so probably not a pure Song Thrush. Blackbirds often have white feathers in odd places.

DavidGutiérrez
DavidGutiérrez 10 years ago

Look, I've added two more photos, apparently those white feathers are hers. In the other photograph, I managed to capture the male.

When the eggs hatch she will be collecting food as well so you should get to see her a lot more.

DavidGutiérrez
DavidGutiérrez 10 years ago

I'll try and take as much photos as possible, but it's not going to be easy because she spends most of the time in the nest. Thank you Malcolm for your comments, I'm learning a lot with you!

A third possibility is a hybrid female. It does seem to have more of the blackbirds yellow eye ring as opposed to the Song Thrush's pale eye ring. Are the pale feathers round the edge part of the bird or part of the nest material?

OK, there are two possibilities here. Firstly, Blackbirds have been known to hybridise with Song Thrushes. Secondly, it could be an Aberrant female Blackbird. What we need is lots of photographs of this bird from different angles showing as much of its plumage as possible. With these it may be possible to determine which it is.

DavidGutiérrez
DavidGutiérrez 10 years ago

Hi Malcolm! Thank you very much for your welcome! I guessed she was a female common blackbird because her "boyfriend" is completely black with orange beak. This nest is in my garden so I see them all the time, and the male looks exactly like a common blackbird. I will try and capture him so you can have a look. Thank you very much for your suggestion, I'm not an expert in birds :)

By the way, just noticed you are a new user, Welcome to Project Noah, we look forward to seeing more of your pictures. If you have any questions visit our FAQs page http://www.projectnoah.org/faq and you may also like to check our other links across the bottom of the page to learn more about us.
Beware of internet pictures showing a female Blackbird, many of them are of the "New World" Blackbird which does look like a Song Thrush but is found in North America.

This is not a female Common Blackbird at all but its close relative, the Song Thrush, Turdus philomelos. The female Blackbird is Brownish, not greyish under the throat and does not have the the pale supercilium forward of the eye.
When you have corrected this please add it to the mission "Birds of Iberia" http://www.projectnoah.org/missions/7726... along with any other Iberian birds you may have.

DavidGutiérrez
Spotted by
DavidGutiérrez

San Justo de la Vega, Castilla y León, Spain

Spotted on May 1, 2013
Submitted on May 1, 2013

Related Spottings

Blackbird (Turdus merula) American Robin American Robin American Robin

Nearby Spottings

Huntsman Spider Common Kestrel Clouded Yellow Spotting
Noah Guardians
Noah Sponsors
join Project Noah Team

Join the Project Noah Team