Guardian Nature School Team Contact Blog Project Noah Facebook Project Noah Twitter

A worldwide community photographing and learning about wildlife

Join Project Noah!
nature school apple icon

Project Noah Nature School visit nature school

Barn Swallow

Hirundo rustica erythrogaster

2 Species ID Suggestions

RyanWarner
RyanWarner 11 years ago
Cliff Swallow
Petrochelidon pyrrhonota
Liam
Liam 11 years ago
Barn Swallow
Hirundo rustica erythrogaster BirdForum


Sign in to suggest organism ID

12 Comments

Hema  Shah
Hema Shah 11 years ago

Thanks Ryan. This is interactive learning and most of us learn by discussions.

RyanWarner
RyanWarner 11 years ago

Sorry bad memory. Right is a Barn as well as Left. You can see that even though the right guy has a forehead mark it's not as white as the guy in photo one.

I know Liam has a lot of knowledge on birds and I'm not trying to say he's wrong. I'm just putting my 2 cents in.

RyanWarner
RyanWarner 11 years ago

I don't see a forked tail, or enough of one to make me think barn. I'm just not seeing anything but a Cliff in photo one. Even the breast, neck and chin just don't look like the Barns that I'm use to seeing. On photo two I would agree that the left bird is a Barn but the right looks more Cliff to me.

Hema  Shah
Hema Shah 11 years ago

Thanks to all for your help and feedback!

Liam
Liam 11 years ago

All look like Barn Swallows to me. Cliff have dark chests and throats. Juvenile Barn do have white foreheads. Plus, I'm seeing a forked tail.

Hema  Shah
Hema Shah 11 years ago

Ryan , I find this intriguing. The second picture is barn swallows?

RyanWarner
RyanWarner 11 years ago

Also they nest under the eaves of buildings (knew I was missing one) they'll build a mud nest and line it with feathers or other soft material.

RyanWarner
RyanWarner 11 years ago

Yes a Cliff can live in a residential area. They don't need a cliff in the normal sense of the term. They will occasionally build their nests on steep hillsides and other slopped terrain. Swallows often feed in packs or flocks regardless of species. It's not uncommon in my area to see Norther Rough-Wing, Barn and Chimney Swifts all feeding in the same field.

Ava T-B
Ava T-B 11 years ago

I agree with Ryan, the white forehead makes it an adult, northern (not mexican) cliff swallow.

Hema  Shah
Hema Shah 11 years ago

these were together. Could a cliff exist in a residential area? All of them were bom diving at me as a team.

RyanWarner
RyanWarner 11 years ago

Cliff in picture one. Barn would not show the white forehead. Pic 2 might be Barns, hard to tell.

Hema  Shah
Hema Shah 11 years ago

cliff or Barn?
Thanks for the Id suggestion Ryan. Appreciate it!!

HemaShah
Spotted by
HemaShah

Tulare, California, USA

Spotted on Sep 5, 2012
Submitted on Sep 5, 2012

Related Spottings

Hirundo Rustica Hirundo rustica Golondrina (Barn Swallow) Common Tern

Nearby Spottings

House Finch House Finch Dandelion sweet Allison
Noah Guardians
Noah Sponsors
join Project Noah Team

Join the Project Noah Team