Guardian Nature School Team Contact Blog Project Noah Facebook Project Noah Twitter

A worldwide community photographing and learning about wildlife

Join Project Noah!
nature school apple icon

Project Noah Nature School visit nature school

Keyhole Sand Dollar

Mellita isometra

Description:

~6 cm in diameter.

Habitat:

Found after low tide (at "East Beach" Saint Simons, Georgia), near a small tide pool (no rocks, just sand), encrusted in moist sand.

Notes:

I moved it into the tide.

Species ID Suggestions



Sign in to suggest organism ID

7 Comments

DanielePralong
DanielePralong 8 years ago

Thanks Donald. Your efforts are appreciated.

DonaldBeasley
DonaldBeasley 8 years ago

Howdy Daniele, I have finally converted all of the non-genus+species level suggestions that I created the other day into comments.

DanielePralong
DanielePralong 8 years ago

Hi again Donald. My original comment was only meant to provide you with guidance on how to use our suggestion box. Project Noah's primary goal if to help users reconnect with nature. We have a lot of rather young users, and from that perspective we accept photos where the quality is not always the best. In many cases this will make organisms difficult to identify to species or even genus/family level. However it can always be the beginning of a useful discussion, in the comment section. We are a small team of volunteers currently without funding, and are unable to make immediate improvements to the site. But we are open to suggestions for the future. Indeed this thread is not the place to make such suggestions; so you're welcome to contact us at addresses provided at the bottom of this page, or message us on our Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/projectnoah

DonaldBeasley
DonaldBeasley 8 years ago

Well if there were ever a chance to ID a Tipulid to species, then this photo (http://www.projectnoah.org/spottings/234...) has a better chance than this photo (http://www.projectnoah.org/spottings/158...).

If there were ever a chance to ID a Chironomid to species, then this photo (http://www.projectnoah.org/spottings/639...) has a better chance than this photo (http://www.projectnoah.org/spottings/871...).

I have seen worse photos than the latter selections in my examples above. All they are doing is taking up space and cluttering organism searches. In addition, specimens representing both of the above families are frequently tagged or described as "mosquitoes." This website has a lot of housekeeping issues.. That is what I mean.

With that said, this website needs to add a comment section on member profile pages. Having this discussion here is out of place...

AshleyT
AshleyT 8 years ago

What do you mean what do we do about blurry photos? There is nothing wrong with blurry photos, so usually we do nothing. From the FAQ: "We understand that sometimes you might not have the chance to snap multiple photos or even one properly focused photo and that is OK, but please make sure that the species involved can be clearly seen and is recognizable."

If you can see the species, photo is fine. No matter if it's blurry or not.

DonaldBeasley
DonaldBeasley 8 years ago

Very well, DanielePralong. Thank you for getting me on the right track.

What are the PN Rangers doing about all of the blurry photos?

DanielePralong
DanielePralong 8 years ago

Hi DonaldBeasley, welcome to Project Noah! In the suggestion box please only suggest to genus + species level, using the binomial name. For any other level of taxonomy just write a comment. For reference please check our FAQ page. Welcome again!
http://www.projectnoah.org/faq

DonaldBeasley
Spotted by
DonaldBeasley

Georgia, USA

Spotted on Aug 15, 2015
Submitted on Aug 16, 2015

Related Spottings

Sand dollar Keyhole Sand Dollar Sea urchin, Sanddollar Keyhole Sand Dollar

Nearby Spottings

Spotting Multicolored Asian Lady Beetle Spotting Spotting
Noah Guardians
Noah Sponsors
join Project Noah Team

Join the Project Noah Team