Guardian Nature School Team Contact Blog Project Noah Facebook Project Noah Twitter

A global community of nature enthusiasts
photographing and learning about wildlife

Join Project Noah!
nature school apple icon

Project Noah Nature School visit nature school


2 Species ID Suggestions

TracyL 8 years ago
juvenile european starling
Sturnus vulgaris Common Starling
Black redstart
Phoenicurus ochruros

Sign in to suggest organism ID


No Common Starlings in Portugal in summer, only the Spotless Starling.
Black Redstarts have prominent red sides to a straight tail.
This is almost certainly a very young Blackbird as it has a large partly fanned tail and a clear gape line.
Starlings have much shorter tails.

Liam 8 years ago

I'm positive this is not a young starling. They are paler, have smaller heads and less proportionate eyes. Their bills are longer and thinner. Plus, they normally have white throats.
That said, I'm not experienced with juvenile Portugal birds, so I can't say what this is, but being all too familiar with starlings, I can say that this is not one.

TracyL 8 years ago

I think the bill and color of it are right for a starling, if you search juvenile black birds you will see that they are more brown with streaks on the chest.

Liam 8 years ago

Bill shape and overall coloration are wrong for juvie Starling here. Not 100% sure what this individual is, but I'm thinking maybe a juvenile Common Blackbird.

TracyL 8 years ago

When they are young they are all grey, i have rehabilitated tons of them here's a link to one of my photos :) in your photo it's much younger thank mine :)

Claudio Marques
Spotted by
Claudio Marques


Spotted on Jul 10, 2012
Submitted on Sep 5, 2012

Noah Guardians
Noah Sponsors

Join the Project Noah Team Join Project Noah Team